How early case analysis saved an employer approximately £14,000 in legal costs
Receiving an Employment Tribunal claim can be daunting for any employer. Even where the allegations appear weak, the business must still respond properly, preserve evidence and prepare for the possibility of a final hearing.
Orchard Employment Law recently represented a company facing claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination, victimisation and breach of contract. The case had been listed for a four-day final hearing.
At the preliminary hearing, every claim was struck out because it had no reasonable prospect of success. This means the claims were brought to an end because they had no realistic chance of succeeding. In other words, our client won without having to proceed to the four-day final hearing.
The background
The claimant was representing herself and had brought several separate legal claims against the company. Although the allegations were expressed at length, each claim still had to satisfy its own legal test and be supported by facts and evidence.
The Tribunal had not yet set the case management directions: the deadlines and preparation steps leading to the final hearing. This meant that the most substantial work – including witness statements, the hearing bundle and detailed final hearing preparation – still lay ahead.
What does it mean when a Tribunal claim is struck out?
A strike out brings all or part of an Employment Tribunal claim to an end without it proceeding to a full final hearing. The Tribunal will only take this step in appropriate cases, including where a claim has no reasonable prospect of success.
Employment Tribunals use this power carefully, particularly where a claimant is representing themselves. In this case, we analysed each allegation separately and focused the hearing on the difference between saying that something was unfair and meeting the legal requirements for unfair dismissal, discrimination, victimisation or breach of contract.
What the Tribunal decided
The race discrimination claim did not contain evidence from which the Tribunal could reasonably conclude that race discrimination may have occurred. No race-related comments or conduct had been identified. The Tribunal recognised that alleged unfair treatment and race discrimination are not the same thing.
The victimisation claim lacked evidence of a protected act, such as making an allegation of discrimination, and the supporting facts needed to show that the claimant had been put at a disadvantage because of it.
The breach of contract claim relied on an alleged oral agreement, but there was no supporting evidence and the claim was inconsistent with the claimant’s own oral evidence.
The unfair dismissal claim was also found to have no reasonable prospect of success.
The Tribunal therefore struck out all of the claims at the preliminary stage.
What the result saved the employer?
The immediate benefit was certainty: the company no longer had to defend the proceedings through to the listed four-day hearing. It also avoided the principal costs associated with preparing for and attending that hearing.
We estimate that the result saved the client approximately £14,000 plus VAT in four days of representation and the case preparation required for the final hearing.
That estimate does not include the employer’s own management time, witness preparation, operational disruption or the continuing pressure of having unresolved litigation hanging over the business.
What employers can learn from this case?
Do not assume that every claim must proceed all the way to a final hearing.
Assess each allegation against the specific legal test and the evidence available.
Consider whether an early application asking the Tribunal to determine an issue before the final hearing is appropriate, while remembering that strike out remains an exceptional step.
Preserve relevant documents and witness evidence from the outset, even where the allegations appear weak.
Take advice early so that the defence strategy remains focused and proportionate.
How Orchard Employment Law can help?
Orchard Employment Law supports employers at every stage of an Employment Tribunal claim, from early case assessment and ACAS Early Conciliation to preliminary hearings, settlement strategy and representation at a final hearing.
If your organisation has received an Employment Tribunal claim, early scrutiny of the claim documents, allegations and evidence can make a significant difference to the strategy, cost and outcome. Contact our team to discuss how we can support your business.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Tribunal outcomes depend on the facts of each case.
